Please see SVN Access for information regarding DokuWiki projects.
Your Donations help keep my Software going!

One equals almost one

I came accross this one recently, and thought it was interesting. Feel free to discuss.

Statement

We wish to prove that 1 = 0.overline{9}. (That is to say, 0.99999…, a repeating decimal.)

Initial Thoughts

Why would we want to prove something so seemingly rediculous? Well, we take for granted such things as approximation and rounding, and are more than happy to take limits as they approach infinity, so it would be interesting to prove that using one is just as good as using 0.99999…, if the situation allows.

The Proof

  • Let x = 0.99999...
  • And 10x = 9.99999...
  • Then:

tabular{0010}{000}{{10x=} {9.99999...} {-x=} {-0.99999...} {9x=} {9}}

  • Thus, x = 9/9 = 1
  • But since x = 0.overline{9} as well, this goes to say 0.overline{9} = 1! Which is what we wished to prove.

Final Thoughts?

Some interesting side notes… the logic in the proof plays out differently for other common repeating decimals. Take 1/3 for instance. Run through the same procedure and you will come out with x = 3/9 which reduces to 1/3. So there's no trick involved in the proof, but it's also worth noting that 0.overline{9} is not representable as a rational number either.


Personal Tools